Monarchy

Ceremonial Monarch: What the Role Involves and the Powers Left in Reserve

What a ceremonial monarch does: the constitutional and ceremonial duties, the 'reserve powers' kept for emergencies, and real cases where they mattered, from Belgium in 1990 to Luxembourg in 2008.

A close view of a white and gold ceremonial carriage wheel
Contents9

A ceremonial monarch reigns but does not rule. The monarch is head of state. They appear at the great occasions of national life and sign the laws.

But elected ministers make the decisions. Most of the world's monarchs now work this way. This page explains what the role involves and the powers kept in reserve. It also covers the real cases where those powers were tested.

TL;DR: A ceremonial monarch is head of state without political power. Duties include opening parliament, appointing the prime minister, signing laws and receiving ambassadors. All of these are done on ministers' advice. Some systems keep reserve powers for crises. Monarchs have refused to sign a law, as in Belgium in 1990 and Luxembourg in 2008. Each time, the system worked around them.

What a ceremonial monarch does

Belgium's official portal splits the King's role in two: a political role and a symbolic role. That split fits most ceremonial monarchies.

Type of dutyExamples
ConstitutionalAppointing the prime minister after an election; opening parliament; giving assent to laws; signing decrees
DiplomaticReceiving ambassadors; state visits abroad; hosting foreign heads of state
SymbolicRepresenting national unity; national days; remembrance ceremonies
HonoursAwarding orders and decorations, usually on government advice
CivicSupporting charities; visiting communities after disasters

In each case the government, not the monarch, decides. Japan's constitution makes this plain. The emperor "shall perform only such acts in matters of state as are provided for in this Constitution". He acts with the advice and approval of the Cabinet. He has no powers related to government.

Ceremonial duties in practice

The formal duties differ from country to country. But the pattern is the same.

CountryA typical ceremonial duty
United KingdomThe King reads the government's programme at the State Opening of Parliament
NetherlandsThe King gives the Speech from the Throne on Prinsjesdag, the third Tuesday of September
NorwayThe King presides over the weekly Council of State, where government decisions are formally made
SpainThe King sanctions and promulgates laws passed by the Cortes Generales, within fifteen days
JapanThe Emperor appoints the prime minister designated by the Diet

In every case the government or parliament has already made the decision. The monarch's act gives it formal effect.

"The king reigns but does not govern"

The idea behind the ceremonial monarch is often summed up in a French phrase, "le roi règne et ne gouverne pas". It means the king reigns but does not govern. It is usually credited to the French journalist and politician Adolphe Thiers, writing in 1830. It describes a monarch who holds the dignity of the crown. Ministers who answer to parliament hold its power.

Ceremonial monarch vs executive monarch

Monarchies sit along a range. At one end are absolute monarchs, who rule. At the other are purely ceremonial monarchs.

In between are monarchs who keep real power beside a parliament. Jordan, Morocco and Liechtenstein are examples. The limited monarchy page sets out this range in detail.

Reserve powers

In some systems the monarch, or a stand-in, keeps reserve powers. These can be used without ministers' advice in a crisis. They are meant for moments when the normal rules break down. One example is a hung parliament. Another is a government that refuses to resign after losing its majority.

The most famous use came in Australia, a realm that shares the British monarch.

The Australian dismissal, 1975

Dismissal of the Whitlam government, 11 November 1975.

Status: Reviewed.

Note: The budget was deadlocked. Governor-General Sir John Kerr, the monarch's stand-in in Australia, dismissed Prime Minister Gough Whitlam. He named the opposition leader, Malcolm Fraser, as caretaker.

The Queen herself did not act. People still argue over whether Kerr was right to use the reserve power. But the facts of what happened are not in dispute.

Sources: National Archives of Australia, "The Dismissal, 1975"; Museum of Australian Democracy, "The dismissal".

When a ceremonial monarch said no

Two European cases show what happens when a ceremonial monarch objects to a law on grounds of conscience.

Belgium, 1990

In 1990 Belgium's parliament passed a law easing the ban on abortion. King Baudouin told the government his conscience would not let him sign it. The government declared him briefly unable to reign.

It signed the law itself under the constitution. Then parliament gave him back his powers about a day and a half later. The New York Times reported the episode at the time.

Luxembourg, 2008

Grand Duke Henri and the euthanasia law, 2008.

Status: Reviewed.

Note: In 2008 Grand Duke Henri said his conscience would not let him approve a law allowing euthanasia. The Chamber of Deputies had passed it. Parliament replied by changing the constitution.

Now the Grand Duke would only publish laws, not approve them. His objection did not stop the law. It shrank his role.

Sources: BBC News, "Luxembourg to reduce duke's power", 3 December 2008; Cour grand-ducale, "The Role of the Grand Duke".

Both cases teach the same lesson. In a ceremonial monarchy, when the monarch and the elected parliament disagree, parliament wins.

Moments of influence

A ceremonial monarch can still matter. There was an attempted coup in Spain on 23 February 1981. King Juan Carlos appeared on television in army uniform.

He ordered the army to support the constitution. The coup collapsed. His role came from his post as head of the armed forces and his standing as head of state. It did not come from ordinary political power.

Ceremonial monarchs today

Most of today's monarchs are ceremonial. They include the monarch of the United Kingdom and the other realms. They also include the monarchs of Sweden, Norway, Denmark, the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxembourg, Spain and Japan. For the British system, see Britain's monarchy.

For the best-known ceremonial monarch of modern times, see our guide to the best books about the royal family. It includes a life of Elizabeth II.

Verdict: the role of a ceremonial monarch

A ceremonial monarch is head of state in name and ceremony. They act on the advice of elected ministers. Some systems keep reserve powers for real crises.

But when monarchs have used conscience to block a law, parliaments have simply worked around them. The role's influence comes from symbols, continuity and, now and then, a key moment like Spain's in 1981. For the full range of monarchies, see the monarchy hub.

Sources checked for this page

Questions people also ask

What is a ceremonial monarch?

A monarch who is head of state in name and in ceremony, but who does not make political decisions. The elected government holds real power, and the monarch acts on its advice.

Which countries have a ceremonial monarch?

The UK and the other realms that share its King, Sweden, Norway, Denmark, the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxembourg, Spain and Japan, among others.

Can a ceremonial monarch refuse to sign a law?

In theory some can, but it is almost never done. When Luxembourg's Grand Duke Henri said in 2008 that he would not sanction a euthanasia law, parliament changed the constitution so that his approval was no longer needed.

Why keep a ceremonial monarch?

Supporters point to continuity, national symbolism and a head of state above party politics. Critics point to the cost and the hereditary principle. Both arguments are political judgements rather than facts.

What is a reserve power?

A power that a head of state can use without, or against, ministerial advice in a constitutional crisis, such as dismissing a government that has lost its majority but refuses to resign. Such powers are rarely used.